One quick comment

Given everything that transpired between Santonio Holmes and his New York Jets teammates and coaches yesterday, and throughout the 2011 season, that April 2010 trade that the Steelers pulled-off is looking better than ever.

In return for their troubled star the Steelers received a fifth round draft pick in that year's NFL draft, a pick that was eventually traded to the Arizona Cardinals (who selected John Skelton).  In return the Pittsburgh re-obtained Bryant McFadden and a sixth round pick from the Cardinals.  The Steelers used that pick to choose Antonio Brown, this year's Steelers MVP.

Yeah, it's a funny game.

Santonio Holmes just loves his iPod

Santonio Holmes kicked off an airplane? Because he did not want to turn off his iPod?

A part of me hopes this report is not true; but a part of me . . . the mean-spirited, small-minded place that hates the New York Jets hopes that it is true.

Color me doubtful: Update

Now you can just color me stunned.

In this new context, i.e. cutting Santonio Holmes versus getting something, the deal with the New York Jets looks terrific; and (as alluded to in Ed Bouchette's piece for the Post-Gazette) places the signing and re-signing of wide receivers during the offseason in an entirely different context. Additionally, one can only wonder if wide receiver is now part of the mix for the Steelers' draft strategy.

One last thing: Limas Sweed is the luckiest guy on the face of the earth.

Original Post
I love the work that Pro Football Talk does (not to mention John Clayton of ESPN who reportedly confirmed the story), and a trade of Santanio Holmes is hardly beyond the realms of possibility, but a fifth-round pick for a first-round talent? Yes, the Steelers could be trying to send a message ~ i.e. that nobody is untouchable ~ to their quarterback but why in the world would the Rooney family (for a move like this is no "football move") simply dump such a talented player in the street?

Dealing Mr. Holmes is one thing, but discounting his value so steeply would just be bad business.

The Sports Illustrated Cover

Sports Illustrated did not have to think too hard or too long about what image to place on their cover this week; and as usual the image is a winner (figuratively and literally).

The following is the text from a press release sent to us with the image:

This week’s issue – the cover of which features Santonio Holmes’ game-winning touchdown catch with the headline “Steelers… That’s Six for the Sixth” . . . hits newsstands tomorrow. In addition, a special commemorative issue recapping the Steelers’ 2008 championship season arrives at area retailers throughout western Pennsylvania on Thursday.

We have had a chance to read the feature article, and as one might expect it is grand! Here is the first couple of paragraphs, as if you required any motivation to get out and purchase a copy:

By midnight half the team was dressed in white Pittsburgh Steelers bathrobes, their fingerprints mucking up a sixth Vince Lombardi Trophy, their cigars burning smoky and sweet. After one of the greatest Super Bowls ever played, wide receiver Santonio Holmes wiped tears from his eyes, owner Dan Rooney pulled on a championship baseball cap and linebacker James Harrison asked if he could fall asleep right there on the locker room floor.

Among the quietest in the group was the quarterback, Ben Roethlisberger, who slipped out of the room alone, his robe covering his civilian clothes, the ball with which he knelt to close out Pittsburgh’s heart-stopping 27–23 victory over the Arizona Cardinals in Super Bowl XLIII cradled in his left arm.

The MVP Meets the Press

Santonio Holmes met with the media this morning, here is the transcript of that session as provided by the NFL:

(NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell’s opening statement): “Before we talk about the spectacular show last night, let me just take a minute to thank all of you, and most importantly, our host: the people of Tampa Bay. It was a spectacular week, obviously capped off by a tremendous game. But we’re thrilled and we’re grateful to everybody here who did such a spectacular job for us in making sure that we all had a good week, and our visitors had a great week. I think (it’s) fair to say that did occur. As far as the game, you all are talking the same way we are: what an incredible performance by both clubs. The Cardinals deserve a tremendous amount of credit for playing all the way and (having) a tremendous season. But it’s the Steelers’ night. It was a performance for the ages. It was something that I think we’ll all remember, a back and forth game with some great team performances and some great individual performances … We’re here to celebrate that. We’re here to talk to the MVP. Santonio Holmes had just an extraordinary night. It was really something to marvel at. We’re thrilled that he’s here, and we’re thrilled that Mike (Tomlin) is here. They represent everything that’s great in the NFL, and we’re proud that they’re here. I’d like to bring up Santonio to get his MVP trophy.”



(Santonio Holmes’ opening statement): “It’s definitely a pleasure to be here. I’d like to thank my teammates, and first of all, thank the Lord upstairs for allowing me to be here and the opportunity he gave me to step out on the field and play to the best of my ability. I’d definitely like to thank the fans for their support (and for) being here, my family, my kids, everybody that’s been there through all the thick and thin, helping (to) provide the way for me, keeping me humble throughout the whole time I’ve been going up and down as far as this season. I’m really excited about getting back to Pittsburgh for this parade so that we can definitely enjoy it all together. So I’m open for any questions.”



(on whether he knows Jaguars RB Fred Taylor): “We’re actually second cousins. So I definitely know a lot about him.”



(on whether he will meet with Taylor in the near future): “I know he’s probably not going to want to bother me now. A lot’s going on. But I’ll definitely hear from him within the next couple days. I’ll definitely get a chance to spend some time with him this offseason. I know he’s very proud of me right now, coming from where we came from, the first guy from my high school, from my college, to win MVP of the Super Bowl. This is truly a blessing.”



(on what he did last night and whether Hines Ward has talked to him about how being the MVP of the Super Bowl changed his life): “Last night, I just spent time with my kids. I didn’t not want to be with the fans at the time, but I think my play on the field and everybody that witnessed me holding up that trophy, that sticky Lombardi, and being able to celebrate with everybody at the time, I’m pretty sure I knew that they appreciated that. But I definitely spent a lot of time with my kids, made sure they were well taken care of. I put on a movie. They were very excited about watching Madagascar 2 last night. We definitely spent a little time together, watched the movie. I really just stayed in and relaxed a lot. As far as talking to Hines about what’s definitely going to change about my life, he just told me, ‘Stay humble.’ Things are going to come for me, (I just need to) be ready to represent my family, this team, and this whole organization, because everybody behind me has my back. (He told me,) don’t lose sight of where I came from and definitely what I’m trying to accomplish for the rest of my life.”



(on what went wrong on the play before his game-winning touchdown): “It definitely can be thought of as redemption. It was a play that I should’ve made. Ben (Roethlisberger) put the ball where only I could catch it. I really took my eyes off of it thinking about keeping my feet down before I got my hands on the ball and just lost sight of the ball. But coming back, and having the faith in me and believing that I could be the one to make that play, he gave me the opportunity in the back of the end zone and I promised myself this time that I wouldn’t lift those feet off the ground.”



(on what he was thinking about the Larry Fitzgerald hype this week): “It was definitely our destiny to win the Super Bowl. I knew that he was a great player. He’s been doing great things thus far in the postseason, but I wasn’t worried about him. We have the number-one defense. We have guys that were definitely going to push forward to stop him from being the big-play guy that he has been all postseason. My thoughts, though, on how the game played out: it played exactly how it was supposed to. Our defense stepped up when they needed to. They gave up some big plays, but at the same time, when they really needed to clamp down on that offense, they did just that. (I) focused on what I know how to do and what my coaches allow me to do. I really wasn’t worried about anybody else. The Cardinals can’t win the Super Bowl for the Steelers. I know what I can do for this team, and the coaches and the players allowed me to just do that.”



(on his fluctuating performance throughout the year and why he was able to then come back from that and be the MVP of the Super Bowl): “Having that faith come from my quarterback and hearing him day in and day out, every Sunday, telling me, ‘Just stick with me no matter what goes on throughout the game, and we’re going to make plays together.’ Just hearing that from a guy that believes in the third-year guy, and allowing me to just go out there and play freely. The coaches, they always have my back 100 percent. Coach T (Tomlin), he’s always been there for me. We always have side conversations on and off the field. He’s just been believing in me in being a playmaker for him. Unfortunately (for the Cardinals), things happened the way we planned it, you know? My off-the-field goals that I set for myself to win the Super Bowl and to be a Pro Bowler didn’t (completely) work out in my favor, but I think that hoisting that sticky Lombardi Trophy works out more in my favor than anything.”



(on his off-the-field incident earlier this season): “The next day, I came in to work after that happened, and I sat down and had a meeting with Coach Tomlin. He told me how he felt, and he told me that he was going to handle the situation accordingly. At first, I didn’t want to hear that from my head coach. I was hoping that he just trusted my word that nothing went wrong, but I see that he put me in a better situation by handling the situation firsthand, getting the distractions away from the team, and away from myself, and allowing me to come back to the team the following week, ready to go. He accepted all of that.”



(on naming his game-winning catch): “I haven’t really thought about it. I’ll leave it up to my family members. They’re definitely going to throw some things out there for me to think about once I get a chance to settle down and talk to the family and spend some time with them. I’ll definitely have a name for that play once it’s all said and done.”



(on if this win was vindication for him and Ben Roethlisberger): “I think those quick passes early in the game kind of got him in the flow of the game and allowed him to relax. He knew he didn’t have any pressure on getting me the ball. We talked all week that if I get (double) teamed in the game early, I know that he’s going to feel comfortable playing the in the Super Bowl and (that) is going to allow him to just go out and play more freely. We all made plays tonight, myself, Hines Ward and Nate Washington, and we definitely can’t forget Heath (Miller). With the ability that Ben has to scramble, get open and escape from guys and throw us the ball, that’s what we do. Having a 6-5, 250-260 pound quarterback, knowing the strength and play-making ability that he has, we always know that there is a play to be made, no matter what.”

Six the Hard Way: The Good, the Bad, & the Ugly

Now begins the most dangerous time of the year ~ the offseason. Remember, it was following the win in Super Bowl XL that Ben Roethlisberger decided that riding his motorcycle without a helmet would be a good idea, and of course a couple of Steelers ended up being arrested.

We can only hope that every behaves themselves this offseason.

But of course the matter at end right now is Super Bowl XLIII, who performed well and who did not. We want to preface our observations with this: Ben Roethlisberger and Santonio Holmes have managed to elevate their respective statuses to something approaching a deity, at least in the Steelers' Nation. We, like all fans of the Black & Gold, recognize that fact but have decided to use this space to highlight some other members of the team.

The Good

1. We get many things wrong but we do want to point out that in our preview we pointed out that if the Steelers' offense had the ball for "something approaching 34:00 . . . they will win the game ~ perhaps by only three points." The Steelers ended up keeping the ball for 33:01.


2. James Harrison was a one man wrecking crew. The 100-yard pass interception is going to end up on par with the Immaculate Reception (along with Mr. Holmes' touchdown catch) for greatest single play in Pittsburgh Steelers history. But he also dominated the Cardinals' offensive left tackle, Mike Gandy, who was called for holding calls (and could have been called for three more), had three tackles, one assist, and two quarterback hits. It was the type of performance one would hope for from the NFL's Defensive Player of the year.


3. Heath Miller may have played the best all-around game of anyone on the offense not named Ben Roethlisberger. Mr. Miller's four catches in the first half led the team, his first reception (a 21-yard reception) on the Steelers' opening possession moved the ball to the Arizona one yard line where they eventually kicked a field goal.
   
   In the second half Arizona's defensive adjustments largely neutralized Mr. Miller (he had one reception and one dropped pass), but his blocking was the best ~ bar none ~ along the offensive line. Mr. Miller's ability to contribute in different phases of the game, and his continual improvement in all phases, makes him one of the most valuable players on the team.


4. Despite a shaky start on punt coverage (i.e. Steve Breaston's 34-yard punt return) the Steelers' special teams were pretty special in Super Bowl XLIII. After that first punt return the Cardinals gained zero yards on Mitch Berger's other punts (two others, to be exact). Meanwhile, coming into the game Arizona had been averaging 21.0 yards per kick return during the playoffs, but this past Sunday they could only average 18.2 yards on five kick returns (13.4% below average).
   
   On return teams the Steelers' statistics do not look that impressive ~ 2.5 yards per punt return and 20.0 yards per kick return ~ however Mr. Holmes' performance on punt returns was quite good if only because he was able to catch all but one of the kicks (and that one was downed inside the five yard line) thereby saving field position. As for the kick return team, they had only been averaging 18.0 yards per return during the playoffs, so this was a net improvement. Moreover, we are big fans of the straight ahead style that Pittsburgh used, and has used on those returns.

The Bad

1. Ike Taylor had a nightmarish second half, and we cannot understand why he has such a difficult time reading the receiver's eyes and turning his head around so he can see the football while it is still in the air. The Cardinals' first touchdown pass to Larry Fitzgerald was almost a perfect replication of a play that Baltimore scored on in the AFC Championship game two weeks ago. Of course, the second touchdown pass to Mr. Fitzgerald was hardly Mr. Taylor at his best (though, in fairness, the design of that play was terrific, the execution by the Cardinals flawless, and the decision by both Steelers' safeties to bit on outside routes by other receivers ill-advised).
   
   Then there is the matter of the unnecessary roughness foul he committed in the fourth quarter as the Steelers' defense tried desperately to hang on to the lead. Getting beat physically is one thing ~ in the NFL it happens ~ but beating yourself because of mental mistakes and poor judgment are the difference between winning and losing. Mr. Taylor should be very grateful tonight that consequences of his mental mistake were not more substantial.


2. The Steelers are World Champions, and we all feel great about that. However, this team is so far from being the best team in the NFL it is testimony to the coaches that they got as far as they did. More specifically, the offensive was overmatched for much of the night.
   
   Sixteen yards rushing in the second half.
   
   On the final, game winning drive the Steelers' offense gained 78 net yards. Other than that they gained 47 yards in the entire second half.
   
   Both sacks of Ben Roethlisberger were in the second half, and he was hit five other times on passing plays during that same half.
   
   Whether by the draft, free agency, or both the Steelers need to dramatically improve the offensive line if they hope to entertain a realistic opportunity at defending their Super Bowl crown.

The Ugly

1. Three words: Red. Zone. Offense.
   It nearly cost the Steelers the game.


2. We know that if we thought long and hard enough we could come up with some more of ugly aspects of Sunday's performance (e.g. Matt Spaeth appeared to miss every one of his blocks) . . . but the Steelers just won their sixth Super Bowl and we do not want to ruin the mood!

The Lombardi Trophy Presentation

The NFL has been kind enough to provide a transcript of the Lombardi Trophy presentation ceremony, which we are happy to share with all of you.

SUPER BOWL XLIII LOMBARDI AND MVP TROPHY PRESENTATION

NFL COMMISSIONER ROGER GOODELL

“Well, some say that we could not top last year’s Super Bowl, but the Steelers and Cardinals did that tonight. Dan, Art, Mike, Ben and all the Steeler fans congratulations on your sixth world championship. You’re Super Bowl winners again. Congratulations Dan.”

STEELERS CHAIRMAN DAN ROONEY
(on what his expectations of his team were when the season started): “This group of young players was just marvelous. I can’t say enough about them. We had the toughest schedule in the league. They kept going under Mike Tomlin’s direction and it was great. I would just like to thank President Obama and all of the Steeler nation for supporting us on through the year and it’s really terrific. Mike Tomlin has just done a marvelous job and thank you very much.”

(on if there is room in the trophy room) “We’ll make room.”

STEELERS HEAD COACH MIKE TOMLIN

(on being the youngest head coach to win a Super Bowl): “Thank you. I’m also the most blessed coach to work with our staff and this group of men right here. I cannot say enough about what these guys are willing to do for one another and for you out there Steeler nation.”

(on if he ever felt he was in over his head when he replaced Bill Cowher): “No, I had great belief in the Rooney’s and their decision making. They know what they’re doing. My comfort rested in their decision making and all I wanted to do was prove them right.”

(on what he was thinking when Larry Fitzgerald scored the touchdown): “Acutally I was thinking if they were going to score, that’s how you want them to score, quickly. This has been our story all year, hasn’t it men? Steeler football is 60 minutes. It’s never going to be pretty. Throw style points out the window but these guys will fight until the end. And I take my hat off to you and I congratulate every last one of you.”

STEELERS WIDE RECEIVER SANTONIO HOLMES

(on if quarterback Ben Roethlisberger said anything to him on the final drive): “I said to him that I wanted to be the guy that made the plays for this team. I wanted to continue to be great and great players step up in big time games and make great plays.”

(on what he thought when he saw Cardinals wide receiver score): “I kind of lost a lot of composure. But I knew our defense would get us a chance to get the ball back. And I knew we had a great quarterback in number 7. He’s the guy that’s going to continue to work hard, give him an opportunity and we did it.”

(on what the name of the play was that he scored the winning touchdown on): “If I tell everyone that, they’ll definitely be looking to stop us from here on out.”

(final comment): “Thank you. I appreciate it. This is for Pittsburgh baby.”

STEELERS QUARTERBACK BEN ROETHLISBERGER
(on if he had fun) :“I had a lot of fun. I’m really proud of this group of guys. Pittsburgh, our fans, we love you all over the world. And you know what? Offensive line, who’s laughing now o-line. Let me take this (Vince Lombardi Trophy) down to them.”

(on what he said to the team in the huddle): “I said it’s now or never. I told the guys all the film study you put in doesn’t matter unless we go do it now. I’m really proud of the way they responded. Went all the way down the field and scored.”

(on what he learned about himself tonight): “That anything is possible.”

More from Santionio Holmes:"We are going down in history"

(on what he said to Ben Roethlisberger on the final drive) “I dared the team. I came up and told Ben that I want to be the guy. ‘I wanted to win this game for you guys, man. Just give me the ball, give me the chance to make plays and I will do it for you.”

(on the final touchdown) “I knew it was a touchdown 100 percent. My feet never left the ground. All I did was stood up on my toes and extended my hands. I knew it would be 100 percent.”

(on how far he has come from Ohio State to Super Bowl MVP) “This is a wonderful blessing. I would definitely like to thank the Lord for putting me in this situation. I’d like to thank the Lord for helping me overcome all the things I overcame, the coaches for sticking with me, this organization for being behind me and believing in me and my quarterback for giving me this opportunity to make plays for him all season.

(on if there was any doubt from teammates when the Cardinals scored) “There was a couple guys grabbing me and telling me, ‘Ten, you are going to be the guy to make a play for the team. Don’t give up on it.’ I almost lost it for a minute dealing with the time, but God was behind me 100 percent. My guys we telling me, ‘Ten, who wants to be the superstar? To be the superstar, now is the time to step in and shine.”

(on the sixth Super Bowl for the Steelers) “World Champions, we are going down in history. We are going down in history right now.”

(on if there was anything extra said in the huddle on the last drive) “No, I was telling those guys give them everything. This is what we worked hard throughout the summer, why we put in those extra hours in the film room throughout the postseason. Those guys have been spending so much time together, and believe in themselves. I stepped in the huddle and told them this is where we stand up on the podium. We became World Champions. Those guys believed in me.

(on if he could feel his toes) “I knew my toes were on the ground the whole time. Once I extended my arms and my body everything just flowed right together. I never left the ground.”

(on if he could have drawn up a better Super Bowl game) “No. My quarterback gave me the opportunity to get into the game early. They kept believing in me. The plays weren’t there all game for us, but we made the ones that really counted.”

(on describing the touchdown) “There was a play that was designed for me to get into the back corner of the end zone. The defensive backs both came down on Hines (Ward) knowing that he was our go-to red zone guy. When they went to him, Ben held the ball for an extra second and it gave me the opportunity.”

(on if he ever dreamed he would be here) “All my friends, all my family members have been texting me throughout the whole postseason saying that I was going to be the Super Bowl MVP if we make it there. I really didn’t want to believe them because I didn’t want to put such expectations on myself, but I’m here now. I thank all these guys for believing in me, my family and definitely my kids for sticking with me.”

(on if the rule change of pushing the receiver out of bounds changes his approach to catching the ball) “Not at all. Once I know I get two feet on the ground the hands take care of the rest. Once I get my hands on the ball I am not worried about if the defender is close to me. I am just worried about making the play.”

(on what was going through his mind when Larry Fitzgerald scored the touchdown) “Things weren’t going well for him early in the game, but he stuck with it. The coaches believe that he could be their guy to make plays and he did just that. I sat on the sidelines and I said, ‘This just can’t happen to us right now.’ Bryant McFadden and Nate Washington came to me and grabbed me on the sidelines and told me, ‘You’re going to be the playmaker, You’re going to be a star for this team. You’re going to make things happen.’

(on if he was 100 percent sure he got his feet in) “One hundred percent I knew I had my feet down. I never left the ground once I extended my hands. I stood up on my toes so I wouldn’t get pushed out of bounds. I knew once I grabbed ahold of that ball everything else would fall into place.”

(on if he knew he was going to be the MVP) “It was coming down to the last drive. I stepped in the huddle with Ben and told him I wanted to be the guy to make the plays for the team and he gave me the opportunity to make the play. I became Super Bowl MVP thanks to his help.”

(on if the team believed they were going to win) “We always believed. We went 15-4 this season. We never lost two games in a row. We always believed that we could become World Champions.”

(on if he knew Hines Ward was not 100 percent) “Coming into the game, we talked on the way here. He said he was going to give 100 percent effort even if he wasn’t healthy and he did just that. He opened up the game for us early. He was doing what he was supposed to do for us.”

(on Pittsburgh’s defense carrying the team) “The defense definitely went out there and did its job. Having that 99 yard interception return for a touchdown was priceless. The catches made in the game to myself from Ben really helped seal the victory.”

(on what it means to be the MVP of this game) “It means hard work and dedication. I looked forward to the season. In the offseason, things didn’t go my way like I wanted them to go throughout the season. I didn’t become a 1,000-yard receiver this year like I hoped, but throughout the postseason I told Coach I wanted to be a playmaker. I wanted to be a guy that you could trust and depend on 100 percent, and those guys believed in me.

It means the world to me. I’ve lived out the moment with the dreams I’ve accomplished right now. I am just thankful for being in this situation and my teammates for helping me.”

(on the last drive) “It was definitely making plays. It was me sticking with them. At the beginning of every game he (Ben Roethlisberger) tells me, ‘No matter what goes on, just stick with me.’ I stuck with him. He was able to get me the ball. I wanted to move the chains and be that guy that everyone looks up to.”

Super Bowl Postgame Quotes:Santonio Holmes

Steelers WR SANTONIO HOLMES

(on winning touchdown catch) “It was a play that we drew up that we were hoping to get open in the back of the corner. The defensive back bit up on the short route and Ben (Roethlisberger) held onto the ball long enough to get it to me.”



(on how he managed to get both feet down in the end zone on winning catch) “My feet never left the ground. All I did was extend my arms and use my toes as extra extension to catch up to the ball.”



(on play of Steelers offense) “Everything was pretty good and went smooth for us. Ben (Roethlisberger) had a couple of mistakes here and there but he’s one of those guys who knew to keep fighting and win the game for our team.”



(on what this win means to the Steelers) “We’re going down in history with one of the greatest games ever played in the Super Bowl. We finished it up the way we needed to and brought another championship back to Pittsburgh.”

Ravens v. Steelers:The Good, the Bad, & the Ugly

Surprisingly enough, home field can be an advantage, even in Pittsburgh (many thanks to my friend Joe Brugh for the included photograph ~ taken from section 524 of Heinz Field). In a postseason that witnessed an unprecedented strength amongst the road teams (i.e. in this postseason visiting, and home, teams were 5-5) the Pittsburgh Steelers overcame their franchise's history, and the angst that all Pittsburgh fans feel for no other reason than they are Pittsburgh fans, to earn a trip to Florida and Super Bowl XLIII. Here are some of our impressions from that game.

The Good

1. What does one say, what can one say when everything has been said? In the afterglow of the AFC Championship can anyone really question whether or not the Steelers have the NFL's most dominant defense? During the 2008 regular season the Baltimore Ravens' offense averaged 324.0 yards per game, and 248.5 yards per game in the postseason. But in the AFC Championship the Steelers held Baltimore's offense to 198 total net yards ~ their lowest single-game total of the season (their second lowest total was 202 yards ~ against the Steelers in the second meeting between these two teams).
   
   Obviously the most impressive part of that low yardage total is the job that the Steelers' run defense did ~ the 73 yards rushing for Baltimore was their second-lowest total of the season (the lowest total was 10/12/08 versus Indianapolis ~ 51 yards), and came against an offense that averaged 148.5 yards of rushing during the regular season and 91.3 yards per playoff game.
   
   In addition to the yardage allowed, the Steelers defense sacked Joe Flacco three times, making it an even 10 sacks by Pittsburgh against Mr. Flacco on the season. To put that into some kind of perspective, in the other 16 games the Ravens played this season Mr. Flacco was sacked a total of 25 times.
   
   During the previous 18 games Joe Flacco threw 12 interceptions. On Sunday the Steelers picked off three passes.
   
   Going into the game there were some who expected the Ravens to have an answer for the Steelers. Based upon this game we are not sure the Ravens' offense understood the question.


2. Every time Baltimore and Pittsburgh play we hear all about Ray Lewis, and what a great player he is. Fair enough ~ he is a great player; however if he is great then what about James Farrior? In the game Mr. Lewis had 6 tackles, 3 assists, defended 1 pass, and forced 1 fumble. Meanwhile, the less heralded James Farrior had 6 tackles, 3 assists, and defended 1 pass ~ and had the good fortune of having played on the winning team. Mr. Lewis talks more, but Mr. Farrior's impact on the field of play iis as least as significant.


3. Special teams were something of a mixed bag on Sunday, but the kick coverage team did a terrific job. During the regular season Baltimore averaged 20.1 yards per return, and averaged 22.8 yards per return in the December 14th meeting between these two teams. This past Sunday the Patrick Bailey, Keyaron Fox, Anthony Madison, et al limited the Ravens to a 14.3 yard average. As a result the Ravens' average starting point was the 24 yard line and, based upon the results (i.e. the turnovers) keeping them on a long field had a significant impact.


4. Troy Polamalu, we salute you. The interception and return for a touchdown ~ on a play which we predicted would be the most important play of the game (our exact words immediately before the snap were "this is the ballgame!") ~ is obviously a moment no Steelers fan will ever forget. But his leaping stop of Joe Flacco late in the first quarter on fourth-and-one at the Steelers 34-yard line kept Baltimore off the scoreboard (and there is no doubt as to how important that was), and certainly set the tone for the game ~ despite trailing by only six points at halftime, the Ravens ran the ball 10 times in the second half.
   
   However unorthodox Mr. Polamalu's offseason training regimen, here's hoping Casey Hampton gets on the same program.


5. Last but certainly not least is the matter of Ben Roethlisberger. The passing numbers are decent if not spectacular ~ one can only imagine how those numbers would have looked if Willie Parker had held on to the first quarter pass thrown in his direction, or if the first quarter pass thrown to Santonio Holmes had been ruled a touchdown rather than an incompletion when it was reviewed, or if Limas Sweed had held on to the second quarter touchdown pass thrown to him ~ but what pleased us most was that he threw no interceptions and did not fumble the football. He created opportunities by moving around in the pocket, but when it was time to get rid of the football he did so, and did so without falling victim to Ed Reed. It was a mature and seasoned performance.

The Bad

1. We understand that the Baltimore defense is very strong versus the run; however 52 yards of rushing, and a per rush average of 1.9 yards is putrid (by way of comparison, in the first meeting between these two teams the Steelers averaged 2.5 yards per rush, and in the second game they averaged 3.4 yards per rush). The offensive line did a very good job protecting Ben Roethlisberger on pass plays, but their inability to open holes for the running backs ~ in re-watching the game it was clear that there was little or no surge from the offensive line (i.e. Baltimore's defensive line dominated the line of scrimmage on running plays) ~ has been a problem all season long.


2. We do not have any major complaints about the offensive game plan; however Bruce Arians nearly cost the Steelers a chance at the Super Bowl with a single play call. Early in the fourth quarter, with third-and-one at their own 37 yard line, the Steelers went to an empty backfield, and Ben Roethlisberger threw a very poor pass. Creativity is a great thing, but we question the empty backfield ~ if a pass is to be thrown, why not make it a play action pass? It was a poor play call poorly executed, and (thanks to the Steelers special teams) nearly had disasterous consequences.

The Ugly

1. Mitch Berger's 21-yard kick in the fourth quarter appeared to be what one wag (i.e. Big Dan the 'Burgh Man) described as "an onside punt," and immediately followed the questionable third-and-one play call previously mentioned. The result of these two plays was to give Baltimore the football at their own 42 yard line, and the Ravens managed to score their second touchdown on a six play drive.
   
   More generally, poor punt coverage ~ a problem that cropped up versus San Diego ~ reared its ugly head again, with Jim Leonhard averaging 10.8 yards per return, and had a long of 45 yards. Though it must certainly be obvious we feel compelled to point something out: Making mistakes in special teams play, especially at this time of the season is a formula for losing, and nobody knows that better than fans of the Steelers.


2. Chris Kemoeatu, feel free not to get any more ill-advised personal foul calls for the remainder of your career with the Steelers (he is a free agent this offseason). His transgression turned what should have been third-and-five into third-and-nineteen, effectively killing the drive. Playing with composure is always important, but is especially so in big games.

Looking forward to Super Bowl XLIII, as big as the challenges will be for the Steelers the team (and their fans) can take some comfort in knowing that they got to the big game without playing their best football. However, no one should doubt that it will take their very best effort to win their sixth Lombardi trophy.

Chargers v. Steelers: The Good,the Bad, & the Ugly

Because it was a playoff game, and a divisional matchup to boot, the game between San Diego and Pittsburgh was analyzed ad nauseum. However there are a couple of points we would still like to make.

The Good

1. He receives a great deal of criticism, but on Sunday Mitch Berger outkick his more heralded counterpart (i.e. Mike Scifres) by five yards per kick (i.e. Mr. Berger had a net punting average of 42.0 yards ~ 5.6 yards better than his regular season net average ~ while Mr. Scifres had a net average of 35.0 yards ~ 5.9 yards worse than his regular season average). Naturally Mr. Scifres' net average took a big hit thanks to the 67-yard return by Santonio Holmes, but we still like to give credit when it is earned.


2. Teams are going out of their way to control James Harrison ~ he was double teamed all day long ~ but as a result LaMarr Woodley is getting opportunities to make plays; and on Sunday he took full advantage. His five tackles were second best on the team Sunday, and his three quarterback hits and two sacks led the Steelers' defense.

The Bad

1. That the Steelers' defense made San Diego's offense one-dimensional is undeniable, but we were not particularly pleased with the stat line generated by Philip Rivers: 21/35, 308 yards, 3 touchdowns, and a 105.4 quarterback rating. Frankly, if we had been told in advance of the game that Mr. Rivers would have those kinds of numbers we would have been very concerned about the outcome. Yes, 20% of his total passing yardage came on the 62-yard touchdown pass to Darren Sproles with two minutes left in the game, however it still was a less than ideal performance by the Pittsburgh pass defense.

The Ugly

1. The kickoff coverage unit has been a strength throughout the season ~ in fact they were the #1 unit in the NFL during the regular season ~ but on Sunday they nearly allowed the Chargers to climb back into the game on the strength of the 63-yard return by Mr. Sproles. Unfortunately, it seemed like old times.

Steelers @ Ravens: The Good, the Bad, & the Ugly

I've made much of Pittsburgh's struggles in Baltimore, and that fact makes Sunday's victory all the more special. Oh, and clinching the AFC North title, and a first round bye in the playoffs, and putting themselves in a position to earn the #1 seed in the AFC (in another locale ~ Tennessee ~ where they have underperformed), all of that is pretty special too.

There are so many things to discuss, but let's begin with some statistical notes:

• The Steelers are now a perfect 6-0 in those games in which their opponent has scored first.


• Ben Roethlisberger recorded his 50th win as a starting quarterback in the NFL.


• According to the Steelers' media department the win versus Baltimore is the 550th of the franchise since the merger of the AFL and NFL, and is the highest win total of any AFC franchise.

Without further adieu, here are some of my thoughts on this week's game:

The Good

1. I try not to get into matters of officiating, but given that John Harbaugh was complaining about the touchdown call in his postgame press conference, we offer up the following quote from the NFL Rule Book: "A touchdown is the situation in which any part of the ball, legally in possession of a player in bounds, is on, above, or behind the opponent's goal line (plane) provided it is not a touchback" (Rule 3, Section 39). Rule 11, section 2, article 1 reinforces this important fact ~ the ball does not have to cross the plane ~ it simply has to touch the line
   ("Rule 11, Scoring, Section 2 Touchdown Article 1 It is a touchdown (3-38):
   (a) the ball is on, above, or behind the plane of the opponent’s goal line and is in possession of a runner who has advanced from the field of play; or
   (b) a ball in possession of an airborne runner is on, above, or behind the plane of the goal line, and some part of the ball was passed over or inside the pylon; or
   (c) a ball in player possession touches the pylon, provided that no part of the player’s body, except his hands or feet, struck the ground before the ball touched the pylon; or
   (d) Any player who is legally inbounds catches or recovers a loose ball (3-2-3) on or behind the opponent’s goal line; or
   (e) The Referee awards a touchdown to a team that has been denied one by a palpably unfair act.")
   
   Given that fact, not surprisingly, the view from here is that the touchdown call was correct, albeit close.
   
   If Ravens fans want something about which they can complain, consider this: Of the Ravens' twelve offensive possessions none began at or inside their own 20 yard line. Eight of those possessions began at or outside their own 35 yard line; and three began on the Steelers' side of the field ~ and they still came away with only nine points. Can't blame the officials for that.


2. Moving on, the offensive line, despite multiple penalties being called against them, was amazing. Indeed, considering the excellence of the defense they were facing, it was arguably their finest performance of the season. Sacked three times and rushed on more than a few occasions, Ben Roethlisberger had still had time to deliver on target passes throughout the contest; and the job that the line did on the final, game winning drive (not to mention the final, scrambling touchdown pass) was as good a job as an offensive line can do. Additionally, the Steelers managed to rush for 91 yards ~ 22 yards better than the first meeting this season between these two teams ~ and 311 total yards of offense ~ 74 yards more than their previous meeting this season; and everyone remembers (I'm sure) that the first meeting went to overtime.
   
   Special recognition goes to the oft maligned Max Starks ~ none of the three sacks on Mr. Roethlisberger came from the blind side (indeed my recollection is that they came from up the middle), meaning that Mr. Starks and those who helped him (i.e. Max Spaeth, Heath Miller, and Mewelde Moore) in pass protection were terrific.


3. Speaking of Ben Roethlisberger, his performance in managing the game was so refreshing. He threw the football away when no receivers were open, he ran the football when there was an opportunity to do so, he moved laterally in order to keep plays alive, and he did not allow himself to become frustrated by the inconsistent play of a couple of his receivers. In other words his performance was a mature one, and he showed the calm of a leader during the winning drive. His statistics are fairly run-of-the-mill (22/40, 246 yards, 1 touchdown, 0 interceptions, QB rating 81.9), but he kept his poise under duress and led his team to an important victory.


4. All of this would be pointless if not for the continued excellence of the defense. Yes, James Harrison was largely contained (and continues to make a habit of crashing down the line while a running back carries the ball outside of the spot he just vacated) as was LaMarr Woodley, but there is no doubt that Lawrence Timmons more than picked up the slack ~ delivering a beautiful open field tackle on special teams, a ferocious hit on Derrick Mason, and a sack and strip on Joe Flacco (a huge play in the game) ~ in playing his best game as a Pittsburgh Steeler.
   
   We continue to be concerned about the rushing yardage suddenly being surrendered by the Pittsburgh defense (112 yards this week) but the scoreboard does not lie, and nine points allowed in an NFL game is mind boggling.


5. Hine Ward was criticized here last week, but this week we come to praise him. One clutch catch, often times going over the middle without fear or hesitation, after another literally made up for the inconsistent (i.e. maddening) play of his colleagues at the wide receiver position. Moreover, his eight catches and 107 yards is (in both categories) more than he accumulated in his previous three games combined.
   
   Well done Hines, well done.

The Bad

1. Coming into the game the special teams, specifically the punt coverage and kick coverage teams, were amongst the best in the NFL.
   
   Not on Sunday.
   
   The outstanding field position that the Ravens enjoyed all day was the direct result of the beat down that Baltimore's special teams delivered on Pittsburgh's. The Ravens averaged 18.0 yards per punt return (even if the 46-yard return is excluded they averaged 11.0 yards per return which is still 4.3 yards more per average return) and 22.8 yards per kick return (5.6 yards more than the average allowed coming into the game).
   
   As for the returns teams, the punt return unit gained a grand total of five yards on three punt returns and the kick return unit averaged 17.5 yards per return (the lone bright spot on special teams ~ that is .3 yards more than the average kick return coming into the game).
   
   The abysmal performance of these units should keep Bob Ligashesky working long hours all week in preparation for next week's game.


2. Nate Washington is making me crazy.
   
   Drop one pass, catch one pass.
   
   I believe that he may now have the team lead in that dubious category; and it is only the big plays that he did make that kept him from sinking into the "ugly" section of this posting. Also, I have grown weary of watching him run the football (either on a designed running play of after a reception) only to come to a veritable standstill as he approaches would-be tacklers. Feel free to deliver a hit every now and again, Nate. But only after you start catching those balls that are hitting you in the hands.

The Ugly

1. Santonio Holmes caught the winning touchdown pass ~ and it is a good thing that he did.
   
   The poor punt return totals? That was Santonio Holmes.
   
   Dropped pass on 3rd-and-6 in the first quarter? That was Santonio Holmes.
   
   Two fumbles, including one that gave Baltimore the football at Pittsburgh's 16 yard line? That was also Santonio.
   
   Indeed, until that touchdown catch I have to say that the best thing he did the entire game was to block downfield for his teammates.
   
   On the day when Santonio Holmes scored the winning touchdown he was the one player whose poor play cost the team the most.


2. A personal foul on Jeff Reed? Now that was a bad call.

Santonio Holmes, are you paying attention?

First and foremost, we are very glad that Plaxico Burress was not injured more seriously by his (apparently) self-inflicted gunshot wound. Without going off on a tangent we are always saddened when someone with everything to live for is killed, or seriously wounded, by any means.

However, for all of his on the field brilliance last season, Mr. Burress is showing once again why the Steelers made no attempt to re-sign him at the end of his fifth season in Pittsburgh. In fairness it must be pointed out that it is not clear to us that Mr. Burress has violated the "Guns and Weapons Policy" of the NFL ~ that policy, while discouraging gun ownership, only bans the carrying of a weapon "while traveling on League-related business or whenever you are on the premises of . . . [a] facility owned, operated or being used by an NFL club . . . [a] stadium or any other venue being used for an NFL event . . . [and a] facility owned or operated by the NFL or any League company" ~ however we have shaken our heads ruefully more than once over the last few days at this significant misstep by Mr. Burress.

All of that leads us back to Santonio Holmes. Since being drafted by the Steelers Mr. Holmes has been arrested or cited by police on three separate occasions: disorderly conduct in Miami (May 2006, charges that seemed trumped up at the time and which we believe were dropped), domestic violence in Columbus, Ohio (June 2006, charges that were later dismissed when the reported victim ~ LaShae Boone ~ declined to testify against Mr. Holmes), and most recently for marijuana possession (October 2008).

An allegation is not a conviction, but how much bad publicity does Mr. Holmes believe his employers will tolerate? More importantly, does he want to live from one entanglement to the next? We hope ~ for the sake of the team and the individual ~ that the cautionary tale currently unfolding in New York resonates with Mr. Holmes enough to inspire a genuine change in his behavior.

San Diego v. Steelers: The Good, the Bad, & the Ugly

We're not certain what is most noteworthy about this game ~ that the Steelers were victorious, they were victorious in the first ever 11-10 game in NFL history (so say CBS, with help from the Elias Sports Bureau we assume), or what we assume were huge sums of money that changed hands when Troy Polamalu scored a touchdown on the final play of the game; only to see all that money handed back over on the basis of an incorrect illegal forward pass call that ended the game. In our effort to decide we look at what went well, what was not so good, and what was downright horrible.

The Good

1. Big Dan the 'Burgh Man sent along a text message during the first half which said "Thank God for Dick LeBeau." Beautiful in its simplicity, yet comprehensive in capturing just how much the Steelers are depending upon their defense this season to be competitive. Philip Rivers' 43.6 passer rating was his worst such number this season (the previous low was 58.8 versus Oakland), and LaDanian Tomlinson's 57 yards rushing was his fourth worst total this season, and the team's 66 net rushing yards was their second lowest this season (the lowest is 60 yards versus Miami). Moreover, their 50 offensive plays was the third lowest total in a game this season, and their 4.3 yards per offensive play was the second lowest total this season (the lowest was 4.1 yards per play versus Miami).
   
   If this was the first time this season the Steelers' defense had done something like this we might only discuss player performance, but the season-long excellence of the defensive unit is certainly the result of leadership from their ageless leader, Dick LeBeau.


2. If James Harrison is not the defensive player of the year we simply do not understand the criteria for the award. Often double-teamed (and occasionally held, despite the lack of a call from the officials) he still managed to collect two tackles and two assists.
   
   And forced a fumble.
   
   And assisted on the tackle that resulted in a safety.
   
   And came up with a key interception that kept the Chargers off the scoreboard late in the first half (and there is no need to ask, given the final score, just how big a play that turned out to be).
   
   The intensity, bordering on rage, that he exhibited early in his career has been harnessed for good (i.e. if you are a fan of the Steelers) and he is following up a very good 2007 season with a Pro Bowl 2008.


3. During our recent visit to Pittsburgh Big Dan the 'Burgh Man and I spent a great deal of time going through the Steelers' media guide, and while doing so we discovered that Jack Lambert, arguably the greatest linebacker to play in the National Football League, waited until the end of his third full season to go to his first Pro Bowl.
   
   We mention this just so that you understand that we understand the full weight of this next statement: Second year linebacker LaMarr Woodley has earned a spot on the AFC Pro Bowl team. Sure, the Steelers' defense played reasonably well last week against Indianapolis (i.e. well enough to win); but as good as they are without him, the defense is even better with him in the lineup. He pressured the quarterback, he was in on the safety with James Harrison, and his ability to drop into coverage (e.g. the deflected pass intended for Vincy Jackson) makes him supremely valuable.


4. The defense was terrific, but there were also some good performances on the offensive side of the ball as well, but we were especially impressed by the hard running (i.e. aggressive, downhill running) of Gary Russell and Willie Parker. Tunch Ilkin mentioned it on the Steelers' radio broadcast ~ the Pittsburgh running attack is just different with a healthy Willie Parker in the lineup. We also thought Mr. Russell's contributions, especially in short yardage situations were very significant (e.g. third quarter, 3-and-1, six yard gain; third quarter, 3-and-1, four yard gain).

The Bad

1. So let's review:
   • 24 first downs
   • 410 net yards
   • 36:31 time of possession
   • +3 in turnovers
   • 8 points ?!?
   
   Five of the Steelers' nine offensive possessions terminated inside San Diego's 35 yard line, but all the offense ended up with was nine points. Execution is obviously a part of the problem, but we also have issues with the play calling.
   
   For example, on the Steelers' first offensive possession they worked their way from their own 41 yard line on a 4-yard run by Willie Parker and a 17-yard pass completion to Hines Ward (that put them at the Chargers' 38 yard line). At that point Bruce Arians called three consecutive pass plays ~ an incompletion, a sack, and a 13-yard completion on 3-and-18. That resulted in an ugly, 51-yard, missed field goal from Jeff Reed.
   
   On their second possession they moved the ball 69 yards, 33 of which was on the ground, but on a critical 2nd-and-4 at the San Diego four yard line a pass play was called and Ben Roethlisberger was sacked.
   
   On their first possession of the third quarter the Steelers moved from their own 23 yard line to the Chargers' 28 yard line (49 net yards), gaining 26 yards on the ground on five carries. Yet, with a 1-and-10 at that point, they called three consecutive passing plays (completing the first one for five yards, and the other two were incomplete) and had to settle for another field goal.
   
   We understand the need for a balanced offense, however we also believe in forcing an opponent to stop you before going to something else. On a day when the running game was closer to being a ground attack it seems that Mr. Arians more interested in balance than simply going with what was working.


2. We sing the praises of the defense often, but allowing San Diego to go 78 yards in the fourth quarter . . . u-n-a-c-c-e-p-t-a-b-l-e.

The Ugly

1. Paul Ernster has to go.
   
   Four kicks, a 31.0 yard average, and a net of 30.8 yards. His average is tied for lowest so far this weekend (with only the Monday evening game remaining), and his net is the second lowest (Indianapolis punter Hunter Smith had a single punt with a net of 16 yards). He has done a good job holding for field goals, but his fourth quarter, 20-yard punt from the Chargers' 38 yard line was horrific.


2. 13 penalties, 115 yards.
   
   Yes, we thought the pass interference call against Ike Taylor (that set up San Diego's touchdown) was ridiculous (if that is pass interference then the rule needs to be changed), and referee Scott Green has already admitted his error on Troy Polamalu's fumble recovery for a touchdown; but our real problem is with the sloppy, sloppy play the Steelers turned in.
   
   Nearly a quarter of the Steelers' penalties were called on wide receivers (three on Hines Ward, one on Santonio Holmes), and two more were called on tight ends (one each on Matt Spaeth and Sean McHugh). In fact, only two penalties were called on offensive linemen (one on Willie Colon and one on Darnell Stapleton) and neither was for holding.
   
   All of this was nearly the undoing of the Steelers, and it is a testament to the good play of the offensive line and quarterback Ben Roethlisberger that they were able to overcome it all.

Steelers @ Washington: The Good,the Bad, & the Ugly ~ the LIVE Edition

Because of some scheduling issues ~ not the least of which is a 7:00AM flight later this week into Pittsburgh (that's right, Pittsburgh Steelers Fanatic is coming home for the big matchup between the Steelers v. Colts!), we will be offering up contemporaneous insights of the game. For the purposes of clarity we will post those insights at the conclusion of each quarter, so feel free to check back early and often!

The First Quarter
What a beginning!

The onside kick revealed what the Steelers' coaches must certainly be thinking ~ that Pittsburgh's defense can handle the Redskins' offense. The performance of the defense in that opening possession seemed to vindicate that belief; but three points is three points.

Offensively the Steelers look inept. The offensive line appears completely overmatched ~ Washington is deploying a maximum pressure approach a la Philadelphia and Baltimore ~ despite the quick-hitting pass plays being called by Bruce Arians. To that point, Santonio Holmes looks very ragged after his one week suspension; and frankly none of the receivers has looked very good ~ is Hines Ward even playing? Finally, Willie Parker has had a bit of success, mostly inside the tackles, picking up 29 yards on six carries.

Defensively Pittsburgh had a tremendous quarter. The secondary was more than up to the challenge of covering the Washington wideouts, and except for one carry Clinton Portis has been contained (6 carries, 28 yards ~ his long was a 22-yard carry; so the other five carries have netted six yards).

Special teams have been adequate, even with the unsuccessful onside kick. The new long snapper, Jared Retkofsky has done his job well but Mitch Berger's left leg continues to bother him. Also, the use of Mewelde Moore on kickoff returns seems a good idea, the the per return average is only 18 yards.

The Second Quarter
A tale of two quarters if ever there was one.

Offensively, the Steelers continued to struggle, but their 62-yard drive for a field goal was huge, even only to demonstrate that they couldpass protect a bit, and get down field. In fact, that drive netted more yards than the other seven offensive possessions combined (61 yards v. 62 yards). However Max Starks is killing the Steelers ~ i.e. he's getting beaten like a drum on passing plays, and then was called for a hold deep in Redskins territory.

Defensively . . . this defense is playing amazingly well; and are being led by James Farrior who, frankly, did not play particularly well last week. But tonight, through two quarters, he has five tackles, three assists, a sack, and a blocked pass.

Finally, when a team's offense is not playing well that team needs special teams to step up. Santonio Holmes' struggles seemingly are extending to punt returns, but there are no words to describe how big Andre Frazier's blocked punt was.

Halftime stats snapshot:

Pittsburgh Net Rushing: 46
Washington Net Rushing: 40

Pittsburgh Net Passing: 44
Washington Net Passing: 31

Pittsburgh Net Punting: 33.4
Washington Net Punting: 28.8

Pittsburgh Time of Possession: 14:03
Washington Time of Poseesion: 15:25

The Third Quarter
The injury bug is now an epidemic.

With Ben Roethlisberger out, Byron Leftwich did more than we ever believed he was capable of (we admit it, Mr. Leftwich was singled out for a fair amount of criticism during the preseason). The opening drive of the second half ~ 8 plays, 72 yards ~ was such a breath of fresh air; and despite a -5 net yards on the second possession Mr. Leftwich delivered iin key situations, converting two consecutive third downs to maintain possession.

The defense continued to dominate ~ the interception snuffed out the best Redskin drive of the night.

Special teams was the weak link ~ Jeff Reed had his first missed extra point of the season.

The Fourth Quarter
Last season, at least for most of it, some Steelers fans criticized Mike Tomlin for not showing enough emotion.

Based on Monday night's performance we say that criticism has been laid to rest.

We do not often get into discussions about the officiating, but the roughing the passer call against James Farrior, on fourth down, was utter horse****, and was followed up shortly thereafter by a ridiculous touchdown call. Weak.

Despite all that the Steelers' defense showed how an elite unit plays, with James Farrior showing the way with his diving deflection of what would have been a touchdown pass, and Lawrence Timmons delivered an exclamation point, sacking Jason Campbell on fourth down.

The pressure up front meant that the Steelers' secondary played better than at nearly any time we can remember since the AFC Divisional game in 2005 versus Indianapolis. To underscore this point, the wideouts for the Redskins accumulated 55 yards on 9 catches ~ combined.

Finally, not to be a downer, but we feel compelled to point out that the Steelers offense had two net yards in the final quarter.

We'll have a bit more tomorrow, but for tonight we're going to celebrate a great win.

Sirius/XM Radio at Latrobe

As part of their "Training Camp Tour 2008" Sirius NFL Radio sent the hosts of their "Movin' the Chains" show, Tim Ryan and Pat Kirwan joined 5,000 Steelers fans at St. Vincent College for a look at the Steelers. Here are the highlights (it's interesting that there wasn't a single question about Steelers' ownership situation) :

• The Offense: Steelers are gravitating to a spread pass offense and a zone blocking scheme on the run. Mr. Kirwan believes that the Steelers are moving away from the "blue collar," helmet-on-helmet blocking schemes of the Cowher era.


• Wide receivers: Limas Sweed had cramps during the practice -- no big deal -- but he also is having problems with his contact lenses. Mr. Kirwan sees him as a rising star who will have an immediate impact (third wide receiver). Kevin Colbert described him as "very smooth," and good on intermediate routes but not good on the deep ball.


• Kevin Colbert: Interviewed by Mr. Ryan and Mr. Kirwan, he expressed excitement about the upcoming season. Other items discussed in this wide-ranging interview included:
  
  As draft philosophies go, whenever the team drafts a junior (see Sweed and Santonio Holmes) "they get them for their senior year" -- i.e. the player will make a bigger contribution in the second season.
  
  On Willie Colon, he described him as having "a classic guard" body, but because he was at tackle in 2007 the team will keep him there this season.
  
  He described the competition between Justin Hartwig and Sean Mayhan as "a good battle."
  
  At running back, Rashard Mendenhall is a bigger, "thicker guy" than Willie Parker who is likely to be called upon to pick up "tough yards" between the tackles.
  
  The offense will continue to grow around its best player, Ben Roethlisberger who Mr. Colbert believes has not yet reached his full potential.
  
  Mr. Colbert found Casey Hampton's lack of conditioning "disappointing" that will "hold the team back." The strength coach and medical staff are working with Mr. Hampton in an effort "to get him out there as soon as he can."
  
  The return of Aaron Smith is great news because he is "critical" to the left side of the defense.
  
  LaMarr Woodley has "stepped into a starting role" [news to Larry Foote?] but has to prove he can do it over sixteen games; but he's very powerful and is always moving towards the quarterback.
  
  Lawrence Timmons is going to work inside and outside.
  
  Bruce Davis is going through a transition from being down at defensive end and up at the outside linebacker -- he is going to be a speed rusher versus a power rusher [think Joey Porter].
  
  Ike Taylor is moving to right cornerback, but having a good camp. Coach Tomlin likes bigger cornerbacks and that is what has predicated this move -- Taylor's skills and size are good, but he has to work on his hands [no kidding].
  
  Having Ryan Clark back is huge -- he is a quarterback in the secondary.
  
  Training camps are being negatively effected by the 80 man rosters -- a change from previous years -- and as a result most NFL camps are less physical than has been the case in the past. Mr. Colbert endorses a plan to have a 90 player roster for camps.
  
  Daniel Sepulveda is not on IR yet -- because he is not a "vested" player yet he would have to clear waivers in order to make it to IR -- but will be, Paul Ernster is with the team for now, but the team is looking to see "what else shakes out."
  
  Mr. Colbert is very anxious to see Dennis Dixon play in the preseason, and the team was very fortunate to get him in the fifth round.


• More commentary from Pat Kirwan on Casey Hampton -- his poor condition puts all of the nose tackles at greater risk of injury. Because Mr. Hampton is not taking reps in practice Chris Hoke and Nick Eason are getting a greater work load.


• Max Starks interviewed -- he enjoyed the morning off (Coach Tomlin gave everyone a break) and the temperate weather. Other thoughts from Mr. Starks:
  
  The competition between himself and Willie Colon is "great" but he has had zero reps with the first team, and has no reps against the first team defense, so far this week. He expects to get some next week. His take is that the coaches are trying to determine whether or not he fits into what is still a new system.
  
  The scheme is much more pass oriented, single back, play action pass oriented.
  
  LaMarr Woodley has improved his pass rush tremendously from last season, and has had "Kevin Green in his ear for the past four days."
  
  "G-Power" blocking -- i.e. power blocking schemes -- were installed Wednesday.
  
  Trai Essex has done "a great job" playing left guard, and the center battle "is pretty heated."
  
  The Steelers' offensive personnel is still built around hard core running and is transitioning to a "more finesse" style of offense.
  
  Bruce Davis looks "average right now" but is still finding his way in the system --m he showed flashes in Wednesdays practice.
  
  Rashard Mendenhall "loves to power between the tackles" and Limas Sweed is "a great vertical receiver."


• Chis Hoke: Casey Hampton being out isn't having a terribly big effect on the amount of work he's getting.
  
  Aaron Smith looks good, looks healthy.
  
  Lawrence Timmons is doing well, he's delivered some big hits -- the competition between him and Larry Foote is very spirited.
  
  Rashard Mendenhall looks very good.
  
  The young players did a great job of preparing for camp. They are not making the typical rookie mistakes.
  
  Dick LeBeau is installing some new blitzes into the defensive playbook.


• Aaron Smith: He's doing well and feels great.
  
  Watching the defense struggle at the end of last season was the most frustrating part of the injury he suffered.
  
  The players are rallying around Casey Hampton, and he's confident that he will be on the field soon.
  
  Because the defense is a veteran group the camp "seems to be progressing much faster" than in previous years.
  
  Dick LeBeau draws up plays "that [are] amazing."
  
  LaMarr Woodley looks great, is transitioning well to "playing in space," has lost weight, and much is expected of him this season.
  
  Coach Tomlin is doing a good job of pushing the team hard but not too hard. He is someone who the players gravitate towards.


• Mr. Ryan and Mr. Kirwan posit that Justin Hartwig will eventually be the starting center (once he learns the system), and that Sean Mayhan is going to end up being the backup guard.
  
  Additionally, Dennis Dixon looked good in the practice they watched -- the knee looks as though it is sound.
  
  Deshea Townsend has moved to left corner and Ike Taylor has moved to right corner. The reason(s) for the switch are not immediately clear.


• Heath Miller: The best player on the offense is the quarterback, and the offense is being built around him.
  
  Willie Parker looks good and will be ready to go.
  
  Mike Tomlin is approaching his second training camp in a manner similar to his first.
  
  Matt Spaeth is great blocker and someone who can learn from.
  
  Ryan Clark is "back with a little bit of a vengeance."


• Larry Foote: He's feeling very tired and is grateful for the morning off.
  
  The media is talking about the competition between himself and Lawrence Timmons but he hasn't heard anything from the coaches.
  
  He's feeling good, feeling quick, and is healthy.
  
  He declined to discuss the situation with Casey Hampton but did say that he "went through some issues" during the offseason.
  
  The competition between the offensive linemen ("everybody knows how dirty offensive linemen can be") is very intense.
  
  "I've lost to the [Browns] once in seven years. When they start winning some games we'll start talking about them."


• Lawrence Timmons: Is working mostly MAC linebacker (the linebacker who lines up on the open side of the offense), but has worked some outside, and some special teams as well.
  
  Justin Hartwig is doing well.
  
  Casey Hampton is "going to be fine" and has "already shown what kind of player he is."
  
  Dick LeBeau is spending time showing him how to improve his pass rush.
  
  Rashard Mendenhall reads the field well, is low to the field, and very compact.


• Bryant McFadden: The schedule is going to be a challenge, and camp is an opportunity to gel as teammates.
  
  Dick Lebeau's playbook is designed to put players in a position to make plays and take advantage of their abilities.
  
  Most offenses come out in three receiver sets and that requires that the Steelers defense spend a majority of the time in the nickle or dime package.
  
  The AFC North has a large number of outstanding wide recivers.
  
  The mental aspects of the NFL -- i.e. learning schemes and understanding how offenses operate -- is the toughest part of the transition from college to pro football.
  
  The rules of the NFL make it very difficult to cover receivers.
  
  Limas Sweed is doing a good job of picking up the offense, does a good job of getting off of press coverage, and has soft hands.
  
  Rashard Mendenhall has good feet and is having a good camp so far.
  
  The pass rush is looking good.
  
  Coach Tomlin is pacing camp a bit differently than last year -- not quite as physical.


• Tunch Ilkin: So far the camp has been physical and the team looks good.
  
  Ben Roethlisberger is practicing with great confidence. The offense is featuring lots of no-huddle.
  
  The Steelers' defense is going all-out to stop the Steelers' offense.
  
  Despite the changes in the offense, fans can expect the team to play a physical brand of football that will feature the run.
  
  Willie Colon is run blocking well, but does struggle a little on a defender playing wide. Mr. Colon plays with more attitude than even Alan Faneca.
  
  Marvel Smith is in good condition and playing well.
  
  Limas Sweed found out he couldn't see without contact lenses, and is now picking up the ball much better.
  
  Ben Roethlisberger is only 26 years old and is still improving.
  
  Deshea Townsend is the best at tracking the ball in the air, and never gets lost going from the ball to the man.


• Santonio Holmes: Practice is tough but it's going well.
  
  Ben Roethlisberger is throwing the ball well.
  
  He feels as though he's practicing better -- i.e. when to go all-out and when not to -- than he ever has before. Hines Ward has taught him how to do that.
  
  He is improving his ability to scramble with Ben Roethlisberger.
  
  He's becoming a "2-and-5 guy" (five yards in two strides).
  
  The Nike Vision contacts cut down glare, especially during day games.
  
  Ben Roethlisberger is communicating with his receivers much better.
  
  Hines Ward is a student of the game and a teacher.
  
  Deshea Townsend "knows everything."


• Carey Davis: Playing mostly at fullback so far in camp.
  
  In the stretch play the fullback has to read the defense with the running back.
  
  Coach Tomlin understands his players better, and camp this year has been different.
  
  He is playing on every special team.
  
  Lawrence Timmons "doesn't understand that we're teammates . . . he's a linebacker" [he said with a chuckle].
  
  The Steelers' defense moves around more than most of the defenses that the Steelers will actually play against.
  
  Dennis Dixon is doing well -- he is fast and has a strong arm.

Top Two Picks Sign, How Does it Compare?

As predicted by Mike Tomlin, and reported by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Rashard Mendenhall and Limas Sweed have signed contracts and will report on-time to Latrobe.

For your consideration here, as reported by Pro Football Weekly, are the terms of the Steelers' first-round picks from 2000-2008.

• 2000: Plaxico Burress, Michigan State, 8th pick, $14,398,000, $5,5000,000 signing bonus


• 2001: Casey Hampton, Texas, 19th pick, 5 years, $6,760,000, $3,090,000 signing bonus.


• 2002: Kendall Simmons, Auburn, 30th pick, 5 years, $6,214,000, $3,214,000 signing bonus.


• 2003: Troy Polamalu, USC, 16th pick, 5 years, $8,265,000, $4,400,000 "total bonuses."


• 2004: Ben Roethlisberger, 11th pick, Miami of Ohio, 6 years, $40,000,000 maximum, $9,000,000 signing bonus.


• 2005: Heath Miller, 30th pick, Virginia, 5 years, $6,890,000, $3,950,000 guaranteed.


• 2006: Santonio Holmes, 25th pick, The Ohio State State University, 5 years, $8,100,000, $5,700,000 guaranteed.


• 2007: Lawrence Timmons, 15th pick, Florida State, 5 years, $11,900,000, $8,300,000 guaranteed.


• 2008: Rashard Mendenhall, 23rd pick, Illinois, 5 years, $12,550,000, $6,830,000 guaranteed.

Jacksonville's Top Ten

Generally speaking, Pittsburgh Steelers Fanatic doesn't get caught up in individual/one-on-one matchups as it relates to the outcome of a game. Unlike baseball, football is actually a team game with component parts (i.e. players) working hand-in-hand to create conditions that enhance the likelihood of winning. So, rather than "player X has to beat player Y," we tend to focus on fundamentals (e.g. turnovers, line surge, "gap integrity" -- a phrase that is new to us, and which we love!). In that spirit we offer up the ten things that the Jaguars have to do to beat the Steelers, as presented at Jaguars.com; and it's presented here because most of these ten things are also important to a Steelers win as well.

1. Hold onto the ball—One interception nearly cost the Jaguars the last game. Ball security is job one.

2. Rush the passer—It’s likely to be all Ben all the time, and that puts a premium on the pass-rush.

3. Run the ball—The Steelers will load up against it. If the Jaguars are able to run with any semblance of the success they had against the Steelers on Dec. 16, the Jaguars could win comfortably. Note: This is THE KEY to the game for the Steelers. In an interview on NFL Radio on Thursday, the Steelers "have to control the clock . . . and keep the [Jacksonville] defense on the field." In the first half of their first meeting Jacksonville led at the half 10-7, and rushed for 98 yards. As bad as that was, Jacksonville came out with their first possession of the second half and reeled-off a 74 yard, 20 play drive that featured 41 yards of rushing.

4. Play with poise—The Steelers are a playoff-experienced team. The Jaguars are not. Poise in the playoffs is critical. The Jaguars have to find it early in this game.

5. Get a lead—It would keep the Steelers from gaining momentum.

6. Win the QB battle—The team that does usually wins, and that’s especially true in the playoffs. Postseason performance is the true mark of a quarterback. Note: Ben Roethlisberger is the better of the two quarterbacks, but the patchwork offensive line responsible for protecting him isn't anywhere as good as Jacksonville's (see item #2). If Mr. Roethlisberger can remain upright throughout the day the Steelers have a chance.

7. Be special—Jaguars special teams played horribly in the last meeting between the two teams. The Steelers have had major problems on special teams this season and the Jaguars should enjoy a major advantage in this aspect of the game. Note: This may be overstating things a bit, but the Steelers' special teams did outplay the special teams of the Jaguars. Jacksonville averaged under 20 yards per kick return, under 4 yards per punt return, and the Jags' punter had a net average of 26.6 yards -- though he did have three punts downed inside the Steelers' 20 yard line.

8. Win the physical battle, again—The Jaguars are the more physical team. This should be a given.

9. Beware Holmes—Santonio Holmes is the Steelers’ home-run hitter. He has the kind of speed and athletic talent that should be feared and respected.

10. Seize the moment—This is the Jaguars’ portal to so many good things. This is a game that could deepen the roots of professional football in Jacksonville. This is a game that could truly earn the Jaguars national respect. A win would likely send the Jaguars to New England for a chance to make history. A loss would ruin everything.

Preseason Impressions: Philadelphia v. Steelers

I wanted to watch the game a second time before unleashing my comments upon the world, and having done that here's what I I'm pretty sure I saw:

#1. Barring injuries, the Steelers defense may be the best in the NFL this season: How much worse could things have gone for the Steelers during the first quarter? A horrible interception, a Gardocki-esque punt from their own end zone, a goal line fumble -- the scoreboard could have been an ugly thing. Instead, following the interception and after an initial first down, the Steelers' defense pushed Philadelphia's offense back towards midfield. Building upon that early effectiveness the front line defense limited the Eagles to 89 total yards in the first half, and a third down efficiency of 14%. But beyond the numbers what has been especially impressive has been the way the unit is hitting (see William Gay in preseason game #1, and Anthony Smith in preseason game #3). It appears that the defense is developing into not just an effective group, but a nasty group as well -- something that all fans of the Black & Gold would celebrate.

#2. The different faces of Ben Roethlisberger: At times the Steelers' quarterback showed some good decision-making skills (e.g. checking off to underneath receivers, using his feet to avoid pressure, throwing the ball away when nothing was available) and was fairly accurate with his passes. Then, at other times, he flashed the poor judgment (i.e. one pass intercepted, and a second "pass" seemingly thrown -- from inside the Philadelphia 20 yard line -- while falling backwards) that ruined his 2006 season. Ben Roethlisberger's performance against the Eagles illustrated what fans have known for some time: when he'good, he's as good as anybody. When he's not . . . he begins to resemble something akin to David Klingler.

#3. Speaking of inconsistent, ladies and gentlemen please welcome Santonio Holmes: On a number of occasions Mr. Holmes could be seen vigorously blocking downfield on running plays -- a wonderful sight to behold! His second quarter, 22 yard catch (on 3rd and 4) demonstrated his fearlessness in going across the middle, and good hands. However, in the first quarter (following Daniel Sepulveda's 14-yard punt) he failed to recognize an impending Eagles' blitz and the fact that he was the hot receiver. Mr. Holmes never looked back for a quickly thrown ball, and Mr. Roethlisberger's pass nearly hit him in the back. Then, in the second quarter, on a deep route Mr. Holmes seemingly quit on the play, only to have the pass thrown in his direction. Despite a seemingly half-hearted attempt to get to the ball, the pass fell incomplete. Mr. Holmes has the physical skills to be an impact player in the NFL, but it seems apparent that his education as a professional player still has a long way to go.

#4. The offensive line would like to know why everyone is so worried: Zero sacks. Seventy-six yards rushing. Perfect blocking on a numerous screen passes. Here's hoping that the performance versus the Eagles augurs well for the upcoming season.

#5: Willie Reid and Ricardo Colclough -- separated at birth?: As punt returners go, someone tell me what the difference is between Willie Reid and Ricardo Colclough. Fair catches despite having room to run, muffed punts . . . Cedric Wilson has been the most effective returner of the preseason, and Mr. Reid has three catches as a receiver -- how patient should an organization be in waiting for potential to translate into performance?

Getting Draft Ready -- Assessing the Wide Receivers

In 2006 the Steelers' passing game grew by nearly 23% over the previous season (2006: 4,026 receiving yards, 2005: 3,104), and for the first time since 2001 the top four pass catchers on the team were all wide receivers. So as is the case with the team's running backs, the wide receiver corp would also appear to be an area of strength for the 2007 Steelers.

Leading the way again next season will be Hines Ward; and though his touchdowns in 2006 were nearly half of his total in 2005 (6 v. 11), has not had a 1,000 yard season receving since 2004, will turn 31-years old early next month, andhis salary cap number will be $5,918,000 (and escalates from there in 2008 and 2009) Mr. Ward is every bit the heart and soul of the Steelers as Jerome Bettis was in their most recent Super Bowl season.

The second leading receiver in 2006 was rookie Santonio Holmes, and the magnitude of that achievement cannot be overstated, especially considering the tempestuous period between his selection by the Steelers in last year's draft and the beginning of training camp. After a slow start (i.e. 5 receptions for 73 yards in the team's first four games) Mr. Holmes came up strong as the season progressed -- his yardage per catch improved by nearly four yards per catch over the final eight games of the season as opposed to the first eight -- becoming the first #2 receiver on the Steelers to accumulate more than 800 yards receiving since Plaxico Burress did so in 2003.

Cedric Wilson was #3 in receiving on the team, after being #4 in 2005. Despite the improvement in standing his receiving yardage increased by only 53 yards (459 v. 504); and the view from here is that his production so far into his tenure with the Steelers does not justify the $2,900,000 salary cap hit that the team will take if he is retained for 2007, especially considering that -- despite his late season foot injury -- Willie Reid is waiting in the wings.

Finally, at the #4 receiving spot was Nate Washington. Considering that Mr. Washington has one career catch coming into 2006 it is dificult to judge 2006 as anything but a success -- 35 catches for 624 yards is a good first season (inconsistent though he may have been). Mr. Washington, who was a bargain last season at $350,000, is a restricted free agent.

Continuity amongst the skill position players is one important factor in offensive success. For example, the more time together a quarterback and his receivers have the more effective the passing game will be. The view here was that some of Ben Roethlisberger's struggles during the first half of the season were the result of miscommunication(s)/misunderstanding(s) between the quarterback and his young receivers (combined with double coverage for Hines Ward). While Cedric Wilson may be vulnerable to being released, as the result of his high cap figure (relative to his performance), it appears that another season with the same group of receivers will certainly serve the Steelers well.